See more
en
Project budget
How to Calculate Cost-Effectiveness in Projects and Improve Budget Efficiency
In projects, as in life, everyone strives to achieve more while spending less. However, the key to success is not blindly cutting the budget but intelligent resource allocation and effective management. Cost efficiency can determine the success or failure of an entire venture. Learn what cost-effectiveness ratio is, how to calculate it, and, most importantly, how to make better decisions so that projects not only work but also pay off.
|
In this article, you will learn:
|
What is the cost-effectiveness ratio (CER)?
To fully understand what a cost-effectiveness ratio is, it is first necessary to understand what cost-effectiveness in projects entails. This term refers to the ability to achieve the best results at the lowest possible cost. From a practical point of view, it is therefore important not to overpay for something that can be achieved just as well but at a lower price, without fear of a decline in quality or loss of value for stakeholders. One of the tools that can help improve cost management and keep the project budget under control is the cost-effectiveness ratio (CER). It enables managers to determine the amount required to achieve a specific result. In other words, CER refers to the relationship between the costs incurred and the results achieved.
Try FlexiProject for free!
Where and why it’s used in project environments?
Now that you know what cost-effectiveness in projects is, it’s time to put it into practice! The cost-effectiveness ratio can be applied to virtually any project where a choice must be made between multiple available options. Tracing the cost per deliverable helps project teams understand how efficiently resources are being used to produce each outcome. Therefore, effective project cost control is essential to keep the budget on track. Examples of such applications include:
- social projects
- health projects
- technology projects
- educational projects
The cost-effectiveness ratio provides reliable data that supports the evaluation of a project in terms of profitability and the rational use of resources. In this way, it helps select the scenario that will deliver the best results for the least amount of money without compromising quality.
How to calculate the cost-effectiveness ratio?
Optimizing internal project costs can seem daunting. Fortunately, the formula for calculating cost-effectiveness in projects is not too complicated.
Cost-effectiveness = Cost / Effect
For example, if a project costs $50,000 and creates 10 new jobs, the cost-effectiveness is $ 5,000 per job.
Sounds simple, right? However, it is worth remembering that many decisions underlie this formula. Firstly, what effects are taken into account? Are they only measurable, such as an increase in revenue, or also qualitative, such as customer satisfaction? Secondly, are the costs incurred only financial expenses, or also the time and commitment of the project team?
That is why budgeting and cost-effectiveness are so important. Let’s explore how to evaluate project investments and measure project efficiency. Here is what should be measured:
- direct costs (e.g., salaries, invoices)
- time and labor inputs
- benefits (financial, organizational, image-related)
Accurate data is essential for controlling and financial project management, ensuring that expenditures align with planned budgets and objectives.
When to use the incremental version (ICER)?
When comparing ICER vs. CER, ICER (Incremental Cost-Effectiveness Ratio) represents a more advanced variant of analysis. When to use ICER? It is particularly useful when comparing two similar projects, one of which is cheaper and the other more expensive, but also more effective.
ICER = (Cost of project A – Cost of project B)/ (Effect of project A – Effect of project B)
This allows one to determine whether it is worth paying extra for a potentially better solution and how much more each additional unit of effect costs. The ICER is typically used in the healthcare sector, although it is increasingly being used in social or technological projects.
Let’s compare two projects in terms of costs, effects, and cost-effectiveness indicators. This analysis makes it easier to assess whether budget cuts really make sense. If the ICER remains at an acceptable level or decreases, then the investment may be justified.
| Project A | Project B | |
| Total cost | $200,000 | $260,000 |
| Number of customers acquired | 100 customers | 130 customers |
| CER ($/ customer) | $2,000 | $2,000 |
In both projects, the CER is the same – $2,000 per customer acquired. So how much does the additional effect in project B cost compared to project A?
ICER = (260,000 – 200,000) / (130 – 100) = $2,000
In this case, the ICER of project B relative to A is $2,000, which is exactly the same as the basic unit cost in projects A and B. This means that the additional 30 customers in project B were acquired with the same cost-effectiveness as the original 100 customers in project A. In simpler terms, the additional effects were achieved at the same price.
Cost-effectiveness and KPI management in projects
Managing a project budget efficiently requires regular monitoring of progress and expenses, which is facilitated by the use of appropriate KPIs. Key performance indicators help assess whether everything is going in the right direction. Using well-defined KPI for project efficiency helps project managers track progress, control costs, and ensure that resources are being used to deliver maximum value. Read on to learn how to analyze the profitability of project activities.
What indicators support cost-effectiveness analysis?
When it comes to the analysis of cost-effectiveness in projects, the following indicators are particularly useful:
- CPI (Cost Performance Index) – the ratio of the value of work performed to the costs incurred, which indicates whether money is being spent effectively. If the CPI is less than 1, it means that the budget has been exceeded.
- Average Cost per Hour – this indicator shows how much an hour of team work actually costs in order to assess whether personnel costs are within budget. If the indicator rises above the plan, it is worth checking where resources are being wasted.
In practice, these methods should be considered when implementing cost control in scheduling.
Cost-effectiveness ≠ maximum spend
Savings aren’t everything. Optimization is the key to success. Here, the rule “more isn’t always better” comes in handy. If extra money doesn’t translate into proportionally better results, it’s worth rethinking the investment.
On the other hand, sometimes it is worth paying extra if it brings the desired results. It is important to remember that budget decisions in a project team should be based on hard data, not intuition.
How to improve cost-effectiveness in project execution?
Cost-effectiveness in projects is a broad topic. How can you improve project efficiency? It’s as simple as three steps. Let’s get started!
1. Monitor real-time spending
Cost optimization tools are invaluable for tracking expenses and responding to deviations from the plan. Under no circumstances should you wait until the end of the project to complete this step. Act quickly as soon as you see that expenses are starting to go in the wrong direction.
2. Compare alternatives early
Analyzing the costs and effects of several options before making a final decision helps you avoid costly mistakes. It’s a simple and effective way to protect yourself from mistakes that can end up costing you a lot.
3. Focus on results, not effort
Efficiency matters where specific goals are achieved. Instead of holding your team accountable for the number of meetings or hours worked, evaluate the results. If actions do not translate into real results, it is better to reduce their number.
To improve cost efficiency in a project, it is also worth using tools for effective resource management. Cost tracking software, such as FlexiProject, will help you stay on top of things. The task completion analysis on the Gantt chart will enable you to identify potential delays that may generate additional costs, ultimately reducing the project’s profitability.
CER vs ROI – what’s the difference?
Although both indicators measure the profitability of activities, they focus on different aspects of it. What is the difference between ROI and CER? It’s simple! ROI in projects indicates the return on investment earned in relation to the costs incurred. Cost-effectiveness ratio, on the other hand, assesses how much it cost to achieve a specific result, regardless of whether it generated a financial profit. In other words, CER focuses on cost per result.
Can cost-effectiveness be used in internal projects?
Internal projects, from implementing a new system to training a team, can also be analyzed in terms of cost-effectiveness. The key to success is to determine what benefits one wants to achieve (e.g., shorter task completion times, better teamwork) and how much it will cost. Therefore, even if a project does not generate direct revenue, it is worth checking whether resources are being used optimally. Cost-effectiveness in internal projects is an effective way to avoid waste, especially where profits are hard to measure, but losses are easy to identify.
Is everything measurable in numbers?
Contrary to popular belief, not everything can be converted into dollars. Customer satisfaction, brand reputation, and environmental impact are intangible elements that also hold tremendous value in cost-benefit analysis within project management. In such cases, it is worth using qualitative indicators that are more effective at identifying effects that are not immediately apparent in Excel.
As you can see, cost-effectiveness in projects is not just a way to save money. It is an approach that enables the company to operate consciously, make informed decisions, and realistically enhance the value of projects. Whether you manage a large budget or limited resources, the cost-effectiveness ratio will help you unlock the full potential of your project.
